Waiting for "Superman"

Last updated
Waiting for "Superman"
Waiting for Superman.jpg
Theatrical release poster
Directed by Davis Guggenheim
Written byDavis Guggenheim
Billy Kimball
Produced by Lesley Chilcott
Starring Geoffrey Canada
CinematographyBob Richman
Erich Roland
Edited by Jay Cassidy
Greg Finton
Kim Roberts
Music by Christophe Beck
Production
companies
Distributed by Paramount Pictures (under Paramount Vantage)
Release dates
  • January 22, 2010 (2010-01-22)(Sundance)
  • September 24, 2010 (2010-09-24)(United States)
Running time
111 minutes [1]
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Box office$6.4 million [1]

Waiting for "Superman" is a 2010 American documentary film written and directed by Davis Guggenheim and produced by Lesley Chilcott. [2] The film criticizes the American public education system by following several students as they strive to be accepted into competitive charter schools such as KIPP LA Schools, Harlem Success Academy and Summit Preparatory Charter High School. [3]

Contents

Synopsis

Geoffrey Canada describes his journey as an educator and recounts the story of his devastation when, as a child, he discovers that Superman is fictional, that "there is no one coming with enough power to save us."

Throughout the documentary, different aspects of the American public education system are examined. Things such as the ease in which a public school teacher achieves tenure, the inability to fire a teacher who is tenured, and how the system attempts to reprimand poorly performing teachers are shown to affect the educational environment. Teaching standards are called into question as there is often conflicting bureaucracy between teaching expectations at the school, state, or federal level.

The film also examines teacher's unions. Michelle Rhee, the former chancellor of the Washington, D.C. public schools (the district with some of the worst-performing students at the time), is shown attempting to take on the union agreements that teachers are bound to, but suffers a backlash from the unions and the teachers themselves.

Statistical comparisons are made between the different types of primary or secondary educational institutions available: state school, private school, and charter school. There are also comparisons made between schools in affluent neighborhoods versus schools in poorer ones. Since charter schools do not operate with the same restrictions as public institutions, they are depicted as having a more experimental approach to educating students.

Since many charter schools are not large enough to accept all of their applicants, the selection of students is done by lottery. The film follows several families as they attempt to gain access to prominent charter schools for their children.

Details

Cast

Release

Waiting for "Superman" premiered in the US on September 24, 2010, in theaters in New York and Los Angeles, with a rolling wider release that began on October 1, 2010. During its opening weekend in New York City and Los Angeles, the film grossed $141,000 in four theaters, averaging $35,250 per theater. [1]

Reception

The film has earned both praise and negative criticism from commentators, reformers, and educators. [4] [5] [6] On Rotten Tomatoes the film has an approval rating of 90% based on reviews from 118 critics. The site's consensus states: "Gripping, heartbreaking, and ultimately hopeful, Waiting for "Superman" is an impassioned indictment of the American school system from An Inconvenient Truth director Davis Guggenheim." [7] On Metacritic it has a score of 81% based on reviews from 31 critics. [8]

President Barack Obama greets some of the documentary's subjects at the White House. Obama greets students from Waiting for Superman.jpg
President Barack Obama greets some of the documentary's subjects at the White House.

Roger Ebert gave the film three and a half out of four and wrote, "What struck me most of all was Geoffrey Canada's confidence that a charter school run on his model can make virtually any first-grader a high school graduate who's accepted to college. A good education, therefore, is not ruled out by poverty, uneducated parents or crime – and drug-infested neighborhoods. In fact, those are the very areas where he has success." [9] Scott Bowles of USA Today lauded the film for its focus on the students: "it's hard to deny the power of Guggenheim's lingering shots on these children." [10] Joe Morgenstern, writing for The Wall Street Journal , gave a positive review writing, "when the future of public education is being debated with unprecedented intensity", the film "makes an invaluable addition to the debate". [11] Lisa Schwarzbaum of Entertainment Weekly gave the film an A−, calling it "powerful, passionate, and potentially revolution-inducing". [12] The Hollywood Reporter focused on Geoffrey Canada's performance as "both the most inspiring and a consistently entertaining speaker", while also noting it "isn't exhaustive in its critique". [13] Variety characterized the film's production quality as "deserving every superlative" and felt that "the film is never less than buoyant, thanks largely to the dedicated and effective teachers on whom Guggenheim focuses". [14] Geraldo Rivera praised the film for promoting discussion of educational issues. [15] Deborah Kenny, CEO and founder of the Harlem Village Academies, made positive reference to the film in a The Wall Street Journal op-ed piece about education reform. [16]

The film was praised by some conservative critics. [17] The Wall Street Journal 's William McGurn praised the film in an op-ed piece, calling it a "stunning liberal exposé of a system that consigns American children who most need a decent education to our most destructive public schools". [18] Forbes ' Melik Kaylan similarly liked the film, writing, "I urge you all to drop everything and go see the documentary Waiting For "Superman" at the earliest opportunity." [19]

The film also received criticism. Andrew O'Hehir of Salon wrote a negative review, writing that while there's "a great deal that's appealing," there's also "as much in this movie that is downright baffling". [20] Melissa Anderson of The Village Voice was critical of the film for not including enough details of outlying socioeconomic issues, writing, "macroeconomic responses to Guggenheim's query…go unaddressed in Waiting for "Superman", which points out the vast disparity in resources for inner-city versus suburban schools only to ignore them." [21]

Accolades

AwardDateCategoryNomineeResultRef.
Sundance Film Festival 2010 Audience Award for Best DocumentaryWaiting for "Superman"Won [22]
Critics' Choice Movie Awards January 14, 2011 Best Documentary Feature Waiting for "Superman"Won [23] [24]
San Diego Film Festival 2010 Best Documentary Waiting for "Superman"Won [25]
Audience Award for Best Documentary Won

Educational reception and allegations of inaccuracy

Studies done by Stanford University in 2009 and 2013 found that, on average, charter schools perform about the same and are as likely to perform better as they are to perform worse than their counterparts in traditional public schools. Charter School Performance Study (2013).svg
Studies done by Stanford University in 2009 and 2013 found that, on average, charter schools perform about the same and are as likely to perform better as they are to perform worse than their counterparts in traditional public schools.

Author and academic Rick Ayers lambasted the accuracy of the film, describing it as "a slick marketing piece full of half-truths and distortions" and criticizing its focus on standardized testing. [28] In Ayers's view, the "corporate powerhouses and the ideological opponents of all things public" have employed the film to "break the teacher's unions and to privatize education", while driving teachers' wages even lower and running "schools like little corporations". Lastly, Ayers writes that "schools are more segregated today than before Brown v. Board of Education in 1954," and thus criticized the film for not mentioning that "black and brown students are being suspended, expelled, searched, and criminalized". [28]

Diane Ravitch, Research Professor of Education at New York University and a nonresident senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, similarly criticizes the film's lack of accuracy. [29] The most substantial distortion, according to Ravitch, is the claim that "70 percent of eighth-grade students cannot read at grade level", a misrepresentation of data from the National Assessment of Educational Progress. [29] Ravitch served as a board member with the NAEP and says that "the NAEP doesn't measure performance in terms of grade-level achievement", as claimed in the film, but only as "advanced", "proficient", and "basic". The film assumes that any student below proficient is "below grade level", but this claim is not supported by the NAEP data. Ravitch says that a study by Stanford University economist Margaret Raymond of 5000 charter schools found that only 17% are superior in math test performance to a matched public school, and many perform badly, casting doubt on the film's claim that privately managed charter schools are the solution to bad public schools. [29] One of the reasons for the high test scores, writes Ravitch, is that many charter schools expel low-performing students to bring up their average scores. Ravitch also writes that many charter schools are involved in "unsavory real estate deals". [29]

In 2011, many news media reported on a testing score "cheating scandal" at Rhee's schools, because the test answer sheets contained a suspiciously high number of erasures that changed wrong answers to right answers. They asked Rhee whether the pressure on teachers led them to cheat. Rhee said that only a small number of teachers and principals cheated. Ravitch said that "cheating, teaching to bad tests, institutionalized fraud, dumbing down of tests, and a narrowed curriculum" were the true outcomes of Rhee's tenure in D.C. schools. [30] [31] [32]

A teacher-backed group called the Grassroots Education Movement produced a rebuttal documentary titled The Inconvenient Truth Behind Waiting for Superman, which was released in 2011. [33] It criticizes some public figures featured in Waiting for "Superman", proposes different policies to improve education in the United States and counters the position taken by Guggenheim. [34] The documentary was directed, filmed, and edited by Julie Cavanagh, Darren Marelli, Norm Scott, Mollie Bruhn, and Lisa Donlan. [35]

Book release

There is also a companion book titled Waiting For "Superman": How We Can Save America's Failing Public Schools. [36]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Charter schools in the United States</span> Independently-managed public schools

Charter schools in the United States are primary or secondary education institutions which receive government funding but operate with a degree of autonomy or independence from local public school districts. Charter schools have a contract with local public school districts or other governmental authorizing bodies that allow them to operate. These contracts, or charters, are how charter schools bear their name. Charter schools are open to all students, depending on capacity, and do not charge tuition. 7.4 percent of all public school students attended a charter school in the 2021–2022 school year.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Diane Ravitch</span> American historian and educational policy analyst

Diane Silvers Ravitch is a historian of education, an educational policy analyst, and a research professor at New York University's Steinhardt School of Culture, Education, and Human Development. Previously, she was a U.S. Assistant Secretary of Education. In 2010, she became "an activist on behalf of public schools". Her blog at DianeRavitch.net has received more than 36 million page views since she began blogging in 2012. Ravitch writes for the New York Review of Books.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anchorage School District</span> School district in Alaska

The Anchorage School District (ASD) manages all public schools within the Municipality of Anchorage in the U.S. state of Alaska. It is the 107th largest school district in the United States, serving over 45,000 students in more than 90 schools.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Davis Guggenheim</span> American film and television director and producer

Philip Davis Guggenheim is an American screenwriter, director, and producer.

The Knowledge is Power Program, commonly known as KIPP, is a network of free open-enrollment college-preparatory public charter schools in low income communities throughout the United States. As of 2009, KIPP is North America's largest network of public charter schools. The head offices are in San Francisco, Chicago, New York City, and Washington, D.C.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Assessment of Educational Progress</span> Assessment

The National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) is the largest continuing and nationally representative assessment of what U.S. students know and can do in various subjects. NAEP is a congressionally mandated project administered by the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), within the Institute of Education Sciences (IES) of the United States Department of Education. The first national administration of NAEP occurred in 1969. The National Assessment Governing Board (NAGB) is an independent, bipartisan board that sets policy for NAEP and is responsible for developing the framework and test specifications.The National Assessment Governing Board, whose members are appointed by the U.S. Secretary of Education, includes governors, state legislators, local and state school officials, educators, business representatives, and members of the general public. Congress created the 26-member Governing Board in 1988.

<i>An Inconvenient Truth</i> 2006 film by Davis Guggenheim

An Inconvenient Truth is a 2006 American documentary film directed by Davis Guggenheim about former vice president of the United States Al Gore's campaign to educate people about global warming. The film features a slide show that, by Gore's own estimate, he has presented over 1,000 times to audiences worldwide.

Sandra Stotsky is Professor emerita in the Department of Education Reform at the University of Arkansas, and held the 21st Century Chair in Teacher Quality. Her research ranges from teacher licensure tests, e.g., (1), coherence in the literature and reading curriculum, e.g., (2), and academic achievement in single-sex classrooms, e.g., (3) to critiques of Common Core’s standards in English language arts, e.g., (4) mathematics.(5), and US History and civic education (6), and other aspects of the Common Core project, e.g., (7), and to reviews of books in education, e.g., (8) She is an advocate of standards-based reform and strong academic standards and assessments for students and teachers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Michelle Rhee</span> American educational reformer (born 1969)

Michelle Ann Rhee is an American educator and advocate for education reform. She was Chancellor of District of Columbia Public Schools from 2007 to 2010. In late 2010, she founded StudentsFirst, a non-profit organization that works on education reform.

<i>The Lottery</i> (2010 film) 2010 film

The Lottery is a 2010 documentary film about the controversy surrounding public and charter schools in the United States, directed by Madeleine Sackler. The film was produced by Blake Ashman-Kipervaser, James Lawler, and Madeleine Sackler. The cinematographer was Wolfgang Held.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">SEED Foundation</span> U.S. non-profit organization

The SEED Foundation is a 501(c)(3) organization, established in 1997 to provide boarding school college-preparatory educational opportunities to underserved students.

<i>Race to Nowhere</i> 2009 American film

Race to Nowhere is a 2009 documentary film written by Maimone Attia and directed by Vicki Abeles and Jessica Congdon.

StudentsFirst is a political lobbying organization formed in 2010 by Michelle Rhee, former school chancellor of Washington D.C. public schools, in support of education reform. The organization worked to pass state laws on issues such as expanding charter schools and teacher tenure reform. On March 29, 2016, it announced some of its state chapters would merge with 50CAN, and its Sacramento headquarters would downsize.

<i>Wont Back Down</i> (film) 2012 American film

Won't Back Down is a 2012 American drama film directed by Daniel Barnz and starring Maggie Gyllenhaal, Viola Davis and Holly Hunter.

Kevin S. Huffman is an American lawyer and education administrator who was the Commissioner of the Tennessee Department of Education. He was appointed to the position by Tennessee Governor Bill Haslam and served from April 2011 to January 2015. Prior to his work at the Tennessee Department of Education, Huffman held a senior management position in Teach for America and had worked as an attorney specializing in education.

<i>The Rubber Room</i> 2010 American film

The Rubber Room is a 2010 documentary film about the reassignment centers run by the New York City Department of Education, which the filmmakers claim exist in various forms in school districts across the United States. Allegedly intended to serve as temporary holding facilities for teachers accused of various kinds of misconduct who are awaiting an official hearing, these reassignment centers have become known amongst the "exiled" teachers subculture as "rubber rooms," so named after the padded cells of psychiatric hospitals.

Eva Sarah Moskowitz is an American historian, politician, and education reform leader who is the founder and CEO of the Success Academy Charter Schools. A member of the Democratic Party, Moskowitz served on the New York City Council, representing the 4th district on the Upper East Side, from 1999 to 2005. Moskowitz interviewed to be Donald Trump's Secretary of Education, but decided not to pursue the position.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Success Academy Charter Schools</span> Charter school operator

Success Academy Charter Schools, originally Harlem Success Academy, is a charter school operator in New York City. Eva Moskowitz, a former city council member for the Upper East Side, is its founder and CEO. It has 47 schools in the New York area and 17,000 students.

Brian P. Jones is an American educator, scholar, activist, and actor. He is the inaugural director of the Center for Educators and Schools of The New York Public Library, and formerly the associate director of Education at the Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture, where he was also a scholar in residence. Jones earned a PhD in Urban Education from the CUNY Graduate Center and has contributed to several books on issues of racism, inequality, and Black education history, most recently to Black Lives Matter At School: An Uprising for Educational Justice. He is the author of The Tuskegee Student Uprising: A History, which won the 2023 Nonfiction Literary Award from the Black Caucus of the American Library Association.

<i>Homeroom</i> (2021 film) 2021 American Documentary Film

Homeroom is a 2021 American documentary film directed and produced by Peter Nicks. The film, which is the final chapter of Nicks' Oakland trilogy, follows the lives of the Oakland High School class of 2020 as they try to make the most of their final year in high school amidst district budget cuts and ultimately the COVID-19 pandemic and the George Floyd protests. Ryan Coogler and Davis Guggenheim, the latter of whom made a similar film, Waiting for "Superman", were executive producers on this film.

References

  1. 1 2 3 Waiting for "Superman" at Box Office Mojo
  2. ↑ Bill Gates Goes to Sundance, Offers an Education, Reuters, September 21, 2010
  3. ↑ "The Children of Waiting For "Superman"". Oprah.com. Retrieved 2019-01-03.
  4. ↑ "'Waiting for "Superman" ': A simplistic view of education reform?". The Christian Science Monitor . 2010-09-24. Retrieved 2010-10-20.
  5. ↑ Goldstein, Dana (23 September 2010). "Grading 'Waiting for Superman'". Thenation.com. Retrieved 7 January 2022.
  6. ↑ Heilemann, John. "How Davis Guggenheim's Documentary 'Waiting for "Superman"' Will Further Fuel the Education Debate -- New York Magazine - Nymag". New York Magazine. Retrieved 7 January 2022.
  7. ↑ "Waiting for Superman Movie Reviews, Pictures". Rotten Tomatoes . Retrieved 2020-10-10.
  8. ↑ "Waiting for 'Superman'". Metacritic . Retrieved 2020-10-11.
  9. ↑ Roger Ebert, Waiting for Superman Chicago Sun-Times , September 29, 2010
  10. ↑ Bowles, Scott (2010-09-24). "The children are the heroes of Waiting for "Superman"". USA Today . Retrieved 2010-10-20.
  11. ↑ Morgenstern, Joe (2010-09-23). "A Subprime 'Wall Street'". The Wall Street Journal . Retrieved 2010-10-20.
  12. ↑ Schwarzbaum, Lisa (2010-09-25). "movie review: Waiting for "Superman" (2010)". Entertainment Weekly . New York, New York: Time. Archived from the original on September 24, 2010. Retrieved 2010-09-26.
  13. ↑ DeFore, John (October 14, 2010). "Waiting For Superman – Film Review". The Hollywood Reporter .
  14. ↑ Anderson, John (January 23, 2010). "Waiting for Superman". Variety . Archived from the original on February 8, 2013. Retrieved 2010-10-20.
  15. ↑ "Geraldo at Large." Broadcast: Saturday, September 25, 2010. Fox News.
  16. ↑ Kenny, Deborah (2010-09-22). "A Teacher Quality Manifesto". The Wall Street Journal . Retrieved 2010-10-20.
  17. ↑ Guggenheim, Davis (2010-09-24). "How did 'Waiting for 'Superman's' ' Davis Guggenheim become the right wing's favorite liberal filmmaker?". Los Angeles Times . Retrieved 2010-10-20.
  18. ↑ McGurn, William (2010-09-21). "An Even More Inconvenient Truth". The Wall Street Journal . Retrieved 2010-10-20.
  19. ↑ Kaylan, Melik (2010-09-24). "'Waiting For Superman' Is A Must-see". Forbes . Retrieved 2010-10-20.
  20. ↑ O'Hehir, Andrew. ""Waiting for 'Superman'": Can public education be saved?". Salon . Retrieved 2010-10-20.
  21. ↑ Anderson, Melissa (2010-09-22). "Ignoring the Inconvenient Truths in Waiting for Superman". The Village Voice . Retrieved 2010-10-20.
  22. ↑ "'Winter's Bone,' 'Restrepo' Lead Sundance Award Winners - indieWIRE". 2011-01-23. Archived from the original on 2011-01-23. Retrieved 2019-09-23.
  23. ↑ "Catching up with WAITING FOR SUPERMAN's Davis Guggenheim" . Retrieved 2019-09-23.
  24. ↑ "At the Critics' Choice Awards: Winners Are Social Network, Inception, Firth, Portman, Leo, Bale | Thompson on Hollywood". 2012-04-26. Archived from the original on 2012-04-26. Retrieved 2019-09-23.
  25. ↑ "Award Winners". 2012-04-29. Archived from the original on 2012-04-29. Retrieved 2019-09-23.
  26. ↑ "Recent Reports | credo" (PDF). Credo.stanford.edu. Retrieved 7 January 2022.
  27. ↑ "2013 Stanford Study" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2013-10-12. Retrieved 2016-01-15.
  28. 1 2 Rick Ayers, An Inconvenient Superman: Davis Guggenheim's New Film Hijacks School Reform, The Huffington Post , September 17, 2010
  29. 1 2 3 4 Ravitch, Diane (2010-11-11). "The Myth of Charter Schools". The New York Review of Books . Retrieved 2010-10-26.
  30. ↑ Diane Ravitch (March 29, 2011). "Michelle Rhee's Cheating Scandal: Diane Ravitch Blasts Education Reform Star". The Daily Beast. Retrieved August 22, 2017.
  31. ↑ "Waiting for Superman" star on cheating scandals CBS News, August 30, 2011
  32. ↑ FRONTLINE: The Education of Michelle Rhee JOHN MERROW, January 8, 2013
  33. ↑ "Grassroots Education Movement". Grassroots Education Movement. Retrieved 7 January 2022.
  34. ↑ Resmovits, Joy (2011-07-24). "NYC teachers counter 'Waiting for Superman' with film of their own". The Huffington Post . Retrieved 2011-11-30.
  35. ↑ "Film website". Archived from the original on 2019-01-28. Retrieved 2019-01-26.
  36. ↑ TakePart (2010). "Waiting For "Superman": How We Can Save America's Failing Public Schools". Waiting For "Superman". TakePart LLC. Archived from the original on 3 May 2012. Retrieved 6 May 2012.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.